Still awaiting test results, DNR issues quiz on fish kills

Toxin killed even 30-pound flathead catfish and apparently all others

Agricultural effluent enters Hardin Creek on Neola Avenue south of 210th Street in Greene County Aug. 22.

Field staff from the fisheries division of the Iowa Department of Natural Resources count dead fish in Hardin Creek south of 235th Street Aug. 22.

JEFFERSON, Iowa — The fisheries division of the Iowa Department of Natural Resources (DNR) has not yet released the results of toxicology tests following the Aug. 21 fish kill in Hardin Creek east of Jefferson, but the state agency has issued a quiz about fish kills and a reminder for manure- and chemical-applying farmers.

The Greene County fish kill was reported to the DNR by staff members of the U.S. Department of Agriculture service center in Jefferson, who noticed dead fish while stream sampling in the area, according to Iowa DNR Environmental Specialist Jake Theis.

The portion of Hardin Creek impacted was downstream from the bridge on Iowa Highway 4 north of Jefferson or south of Neola Avenue, Theis said. The creek meanders eastward and southward through Hardin and Grant townships before entering the North Raccoon River.

Theis said dead fish were seen between Neola Avenue in Hardin Township and 255th Street in Grant Township, near where the creek enters the Raccoon River, but he saw no dead fish in the Raccoon River itself.

“I didn’t see any dead fish above the Neola Avenue bridge crossing,” he said. “So it would have to have started somewhere above that bridge crossing. It’s hard to say how far above because it can depend on the strength of the material as to whether or not it kills fish immediately when it enters the creek or if it has to do its job once it gets in there.”

Theis said he found many species of dead fish and saw no living fish. His observations were similar to those offered Aug. 21 by Greene County Conservation Director Dan Towers.

“It looks to have killed all the fish in the creek,” Towers said, “minnows, shiners, rough fish, a few walleyes and smallmouth bass, lots of channel catfish and a surprising number of big flatheads, many between 15 and 30 pounds and several over 30.”

Theis said DNR fisheries staff took random samples along the length of the fish kill, and the lab tests would try to determine the extent and cause of the kill. He said he could not speculate on the cause prior to the lab results.

“The possibilities are really endless until we get our samples back to see if we get any hits on that,” he said. “It’s really tough to say at this point.”

Towers said the cause “appears to be something more toxic than a low-oxygen-level-related kill,” but he deferred to the state fisheries experts.

Pending the lab test results, the DNR issued Tuesday a short self-exam for people wishing to test their knowledge of “pollutants and releases.” The quiz posed four questions and followed them with tips for avoiding fish kills and a reminder about reporting manure and chemical releases.

“Ask yourself the following questions,” the DNR quiz said, “then read the articles to test yourself on how much you know about pollutants and releases. Sorry, we don’t have any prizes to give out.

    1. Which month has the highest number of fish kills in Iowa?
    2. How much is a part per million? A part per billion?
    3. Who should you call if you have a release or spill? What’s the phone number?
    4. What exactly is a release?

“Avoiding a fish kill starts with understanding why they happen most often during mid- to late summer. Several factors contribute, but remember that fish and aquatic animals like crayfish, frogs and beneficial insects are most vulnerable during hot, dry weather. Usually stream and pond levels are lower, vegetation and algae levels are higher and water temperatures are warmer. These factors combine to reduce dissolved oxygen levels, stressing aquatic animals.

“When fish and other aquatics are stressed, they are more susceptible to pollutants. So while you should always be careful first and foremost, please use extra caution when mixing and land applying chemicals and nutrients, especially during the dog days of summer. DNR staff offer the following tips to help you avoid a fish kill:

    1. Read and follow chemical labels. Some chemicals are toxic in very small amounts (parts per million—four drops of ink in a 55-gallon barrel of water—or parts per billion—one pinch of salt in a 10-ton bag of potato chips or one pound in 120 million gallons of water).
    2. Avoid applying near water, including near pond and stream banks.
    3. Check the weather and avoid application before a rain storm.
    4. Look for and avoid application near small feeder streams and grassed waterways, where runoff could enter a stream or pond.
    5. Make sure rinse water is properly disposed of and doesn’t reach a stream or lake.
    6. If chemicals are applied by aerial spraying, check locations of small streams and ponds before application, watch wind speeds and drift and shut off application when crossing small bodies of water.
    7. Take care with nutrient application. Whether manure or fertilizer, ammonia levels of only 3 parts per million can cause a fish kill, depending upon the pH in the water.

“Finally, report fish kills to DNR field offices or to the 24-hour spill line at 515-725-8594.

Source: Iowa DNR

“When it comes to reporting manure and chemical releases, remember that state laws require producers and manure applicators to report spills to the Iowa DNR. Not only is reporting required, but the sooner you report, the more likely DNR technical staff can help. DNR staff have experience with many spills. They may be able to offer ideas that you don’t think of—preventing a worse situation or a fish kill. Play it safe and call it in.

“Here’s a quick reminder of state rules on reporting releases, especially manure releases:

“Iowa producers are required to report manure and other releases. Chapter 65.2 (9) of the Iowa Administrative Code requires: Producers and those who store, handle, transport or land apply manure from a confinement (totally roofed) feeding operation to notify DNR as soon as possible but not later than six hours after the onset or discovery of the release. Report the release by calling DNR’s 24-hour spill line at 515-725-8694 or notifying the nearest DNR field office during business hours.

“What is a ‘release’? A release is an actual, imminent or probable discharge of manure from an animal feeding operation structure to surface water, groundwater, drainage tile line or intake or to a designated area resulting from storing, handling, transporting or land-applying manure.

“Very similar rules exist for open feedlots: IAC 65.101(9). However, the definition of reportable releases also includes process wastewater, manure, open feedlot effluent, settled open feedlot effluent or settleable solids from an open feedlot operation structure.

“In both cases, if the release involves a public roadway and could threaten public safety, it should also be reported to the local police department or county sheriff.

“Other spills that must be reported include: chemicals, wastewater discharges and underground storage tank failures — basically anything that is a hazardous substance or causes a hazardous condition. Find more information on the DNR’s emergency release page.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.